The 11 Best New York City Pizza Slices

foreign [Music] like an animal New York's pizza places are p...

foreign [Music] like an animal New York's pizza places are perfect for you welcome back to wonderfully lost your home for all things travel today we're talking about everything pizza from classic spots that have been around for decades to newer joints that are pushing the boundaries of what a slice can be so if you're an eager tourist or a hungry local we've got the lowdown on the best New York sizes money can buy number 11 Aces Perfect Pizza fan of some good food and video games Ace's Perfect Pizza is the right spot for you if you're ever going down Driggs Avenue you better pop into Aces for a slice this joint might look like your run-of-the-mill pizza place but it's got something special the Retro Vibe come with a friend grab a beer hang out and play some GoldenEye on the N64 but the real star of the show is aces Detroit style pizza it's seriously the best in the city they've got Sicilian to too but you absolutely have to try their Detroit style keep it simple and get the pepperoni topping if you're with a friend grab the small size and you'll be super happy asa's Perfect Pizza is the perfect spot for getting some dinner and some fun Number 10. Two Boots if you're looking for some bomb vegan pizza in Manhattan you've got to hit up Two Boots the owner named the place after their love for New Orleans and Italy so you know it's going to be something special they have some wild pizza names like Earth Mother Animal Collective and Grandma Bess but don't let the funky names fool you the flavor is to die for Two Boots has this super old school New Orleans vibe that makes you want to come back for more trust us it's definitely one of those must-sea spots in New York City if you want to try some pizza that's off the chain go for the Bayou Beast it's got shrimp crawfish and and dual sausage on it which is definitely not your average slice or you can grab a corner slice of Grandma pie you might need some water to wash down the thick crust but don't get us wrong their Pizza is still Top Notch and super popular for a reason number nine poorly G's slice shop Pauly G's slice shop is slinging some of the best slices in Greenpoint and now they're expanding their empire to Baltimore and Chicago but let's focus on the OG shop where they've made a stroke of Genius by drizzling Mike's hot honey on their pies forget the basic cheese you've got to try the Freddy Prince oh man it's so good their Hellboy slice with hot honey and spicy pepperoni is a must try and the moots White Slice is rich in garlicky goodness plus the Cozy atmosphere of the shop makes it a great spot to hang and devour some slices number eight Corner slice if you love Grandma's slices you gotta try out Corner slice tucked away in the Gotham West Market this place knows how to do Grandma's slices right they use fancy Artisan flour to make it thick chewy yet crispy crust that is out of this world and don't get us started on the toppings the wilted basil and oregano adds The Perfect Touch to the bubbly cheese just be sure to grab a few napkins because these slices can be a little greasy and if you're feeling adventurous give this special with fennel sausage a try the crust is light and crispy and the sauce is just the right amount of sweetness get hyped for a pizza Fiesta in your taste buds number 7. Linda Street Pizzeria lindistry is the queen bee of Williamsburg sliced scene and you know it's good when there's a line out the door they start with a classic cheese slice but that's where the basics end want Parada fig Jam spicy salami no problem their Margarita slice has a thin bubbly crust with a solid Char on the bottom and fresh basil and shaved Palm on top oh delicious the burrata slice is a must try with a big spoonful of creamy burrata on top and a drizzle of good olive oil lindastery sets itself apart by importing ingredients Straight From Italy and some say that their crust taste as good as Bakery bread that's what happens when you take a long time to ferment the goods number six best pizza New Yorkers are crazy loyal to best pizza in Williamsburg and it's obvious why just don't burn your mouth trying to scarf down those piping hot Wood-Fired slices their Grandma's Square slice is one of the sauciest in New York but the sauce works so well with the crispy crust and if you don't want to risk ruining your outfit with drippy tomato sauce try the White Slice with ricotta and caramelized onions owned by Frank pinello who's kind of a big deal in the food world and has been on a couple of shows best pizza is a sacred neighborhood joint and unlike most slice shops they've got a great indoor seating area to chill and enjoy your pizza some people absolutely swear by this joint and we can totally see why number 5. Joe's Pizza make way for the king Joe's Pizza is a classic joint in Manhattan and has been dishing out the tastiest slices since the beginning of time Joe keeps it simple with three options plain fresh mozzarella and Sicilian wanna go crazy with toppings go ahead but people come to Joe for the Simplicity the same goes for the vibe come as you are Joe doesn't care what you look like they just want to serve you the best pizza you've ever had but what about the cues Joe's got their operation down to a science they're a well-oiled pizza machine you'll be chowing down on slices in no time and washing it down with the best Fountain Coke in the city chose the perfect spot to get some bang for your buck number 4. Williamsburg Pizza Williamsburg Pizza started as a small slice shop on Union but now it's taking over New York City with locations all over the city if we're not careful they might go for world domination you have to try their Margarita slice it's so hyped up and it completely lives up to it it's got a perfectly charred crust on the bottom the sauce and mozzarella is a match made in heaven but their Grandma squares take the cake or the pizza in this case it's some of the most fresh and Crisp Pizza you'll ever have but if you're still hungry for more try out their apple bacon slice with walnuts and cheese Williamsburg Pizza is a solid slice spot that is a must visit number three daifara pizza if you're a true Pizza Lover you can't miss daifara the iconic Pizza Joint that's been serving pies since 1965. die far has got multiple spots around town but you have to check out the OG shop in Midwood founder Dom DeMarco personally made every pie for years and although he's since passed the Baton to his sons the pizza remains just as legendary the cheese blend olive oil and fresh basil make for a mouth-watering combination that should to please the crust is crispy and salty with a satisfying Crunch and the sauce is Tangy and refreshing one slice is enough to put a smile on your face but be warned a second slice might lead to a food coma number two scars Pizza scars isn't your average pizza place you don't go here just for the slice you come here for the vibe if you're ever walking down Orchard Street in the Lower East Side you're gonna have a hard time resisting the scene let's not forget the pizza it's this high up on the list for a reason scars stands out from the crowd by Milling their own grains in their basement stick to the thin crust pizzas and you'll know exactly why they go through all that effort for their dough scars is about the only spot where you can drink tropical cocktails and grab a slice of heaven so if that's your motto join the party number one balika Street Pizza here we are the best pizza in New York and it's balika Street Pizza so why do people love it so much it's simple they've got the perfect slice structure a thin crust with a crunchy bite and if you love pizza with the Perfect Blend of cheese and sauce this place is it they've got the sweetness down perfectly they've got a bunch of pizza shapes and slices like the house special buffalo chicken and chipotle chicken not to mention they serve salads and pasta too but let's be real you're here for the Pizza bleeca Streets the best pizza in New York for three years in a row so you better make room in your schedule for a trip here with so many choices New York is a pizza Lover's Dream but hey if slices aren't your style check out our best Nashville hot fried chicken sandwiches linked here [Music] thank you

As the soft dough breaks apart in your hand, and the perfectly balanced sauce hits your palate, you thank mankind for the invention of pizza and the 11 best New York Pizza Slices.

Welcome back to Wanderfully Lost, where Moms and Dads go for travel advice!

Today we’ll be going over the eleven best pizza slices New York has to offer. We’ve rounded up the best pizza joints, and we know you’re already salivating.

Be sure to check out our New York travel planning resources at the end, and if your time on our site is as WANDERFUL as we hope, we’d be super thrilled to have you share this post with your fellow wanderers.

11. Ace’s Perfect Pizza | New York Pizza Slices

Ace’s Perfect Pizza | New York Pizza Slices

If you find yourself traversing down Driggs Avenue and are in search of delectable cuisine, we know where to lead you. Surrounded by a vibrant atmosphere is Ace’s Perfect Pizza, a must-visit destination. 

This establishment offers a delightful opportunity to enjoy a slice of pizza while engaging in some friendly competition with friends over a game of GoldenEye on the N64. Don’t worry, you can sip on a refreshing beer while you’re at it. 

However, the main attraction at Ace’s Perfect Pizza is their Detroit-style pizza, which is undoubtedly the best in the city. Although they also offer Sicilian-style pizza, the Detroit style is a must-try, particularly with a classic pepperoni topping. 

What’s certain is you’ll leave the place already thinking of your next trip back. 
You can find limitless New York City Food Tours here!

10. Two Boots | New York Pizza Slices

Two Boots | New York Pizza Slices

Vegan lovers, we see you, and you’re not forgotten. 

If you are seeking exceptional vegan pizza in Manhattan, Two Boots is an absolute must-visit destination. The owner’s fondness for both New Orleans and Italy serves as the inspiration for the establishment’s name. 

The pizza varieties are aptly titled with names such as Earth Mother, Animal Collective, and Grandma Bess, exuding a playful and quirky essence.

To experience a particularly unique slice, the Bayou Beast pizza is an excellent option. It features shrimp, crawfish, and andouille sausage which truly sets it apart from other pizza offerings. 

Undoubtedly, Two Boots’ pizza is in high demand for a reason, and its popularity is a testament to the superb quality of its offerings.
If you’re in need of more vegan options, we love this Vegan Food Tour!

9. Paulie Gee’s Slice Shop | New York Pizza SLices

Paulie Gee’s Slice Shop | New York Pizza SLices

If you’re a New Yorker, then Paulie Giannone is a name familiar to you, and we bet Paulie Gee’s is a favourite. 

One standout example here is the Freddy Prince, an upside-down Sicilian with fresh mozzarella that pays homage to Giannone’s favourite square, Prince Street’s Soho Square, and a place in Whitestone called Freddy’s, which puts sesame seeds on the crust’s bottom. 

In addition to these options, there is also a complete selection of vegan pies made with Numu vegan mozzarella and vegan pepperoni. 

While not explicitly part of the menu, the orange booths in the restaurant were inspired by Joe’s Pizzeria in Martinsville, New Jersey, and offer a nostalgic nod to the past.

8. Corner Slice | New York Pizza Slices

Corner Slice | New York Pizza Slices

For pizza lovers seeking an exceptional grandma slice experience, a visit to Corner Slice at Gotham West Market is a must. Corner Slice is renowned for its use of artisan flour, which produces a thick, chewy, and crispy crust that takes this classic style to a whole new level.

Now, what sets Corner Slice apart is its imaginative toppings. The combination of wilted basil and oregano with bubbly cheese is a delightful pairing that will transport your taste buds to pizza paradise. For the more adventurous, their special fennel sausage pizza is an absolute must-try.

It’s worth noting that Corner Slice’s pizzas can be a tad greasy, so make sure to grab some napkins before diving in.

7. L’Industrie Pizzeria | New York Pizza Slices

L’Industrie Pizzeria | New York Pizza Slices

L’Industrie has taken the New York pizza scene to a whole new level. This Williamsburg establishment brings together the thin crust of the Roman pizza, imported Italian toppings, and a funky-flavoured dough thanks to a long fermentation process.

The crust is a perfect blend of crunch and puff, with a bakery-style taste that’s not typical of pizza. The minimal tomato sauce and precise oven temperatures ensure that the layer of rich mozzarella remains perfectly in place.

Every slice comes with a generous sprinkle of basil and parmesan for an herbaceous and salt-studded finish. Burrata, a sometimes-overused ingredient, is done justice here. Instead of an overpowering burst of goo, you get a manageable and delightful bite of dairy.

6. Best Pizza | New York Pizza Slices

Best Pizza | New York Pizza Slices

In the heart of Williamsburg, Brooklyn, lies Best Pizza, a pizza joint that has earned the unwavering loyalty of New Yorkers. And for good reason. The wood-fired slices are piping hot and might require a brief moment to cool down, but trust us, it’s worth the wait.

Their grandma square slice stands out with a flavorful sauce that perfectly complements the crispy crust. And for those who prefer a cleaner eating experience, the white slice with ricotta and caramelized onions is a fantastic alternative.
Best Pizza’s ardent following is a testament to its excellence, and it’s not difficult to see why.

Why not indulge in a brewery tour while you’re in Brooklyn, too?!

5. Joe’s Pizza | New York Pizza Slices

Joe’s Pizza | New York Pizza Slices

Okay, we know you’ve been waiting for this one.

The pizza place that thrives on simplicity but perfection is Joe’s Pizza. Joe’s Pizza in Manhattan has been a long-standing favourite for many. It’s also consistently earned the title of the best slice in the city.

The key lies in their limited menu. They offer three standard options. You have the plain, fresh mozzarella and the Sicilian. Now, they do offer additional toppings but it’s best to have it as it is.

With a never-ending customer flow, the joint works like a well-oiled machine. Like clockwork, it churns out hot and savory pies without delay. Unlike other popular pizzerias, Joe’s efficient operation ensures that even during peak hours, customers can quickly grab their slices and go.

4. Williamsburg Pizza | New York Pizza Slices

Williamsburg Pizza | New York Pizza Slices

Williamsburg Pizza originated as a small local slice shop situated on Union Street, but its popularity and customer demand enabled it to expand and establish locations all over New York City. It’s no surprise that it’s raised the bar for its competitors, and is only getting better.

They pride themselves on offering the best Margherita slices, and the perfectly charred crust, with a melt-in-your-mouth mozzarella topping, is hard to beat. But their grandma squares, featuring fresh and crisp ingredients, are a must-try for pizza enthusiasts.

Worry not, they’re not just offering a classic pizza. They also boast unique creations such as their Apple Bacon slice with walnuts and cheese, which is sure to tantalize your taste buds.

3. Di Fara Pizza | New York Pizza Slices

Di Fara Pizza | New York Pizza Slices

Now, make way for the iconic Di Fara Pizza. Since 1965, this hit pizza joint has been serving up some of the tastiest pies in town. Head on over to the original shop in Midwood, too. 

The Founder Dom DeMarco would personally bake every single pizza. Now, he’s passed on the candle to his sons. Rest assured, the taste and quality have not been deterred. The cheese blend, olive oil, and fresh basil create a scrumptiously unique flavor combination that will leave you ordering a few more slices. 

Of course, the toppings alone don’t make this pizza a must-have. The crust is crispy, salty, and perfectly crunchy. And the sauce is tangy while still refreshing. After one slice, you’ll want another. Then how fast you slip into a food coma is not for us to predict.

2. Scarr’s Pizza | New York Pizza Slices

Scarr’s Pizza | New York Pizza Slices

Scarr’s Pizza is not your run-of-the-mill pizzeria. Its appeal lies not only in the quality of its pizzas but also in the lively atmosphere that draws you in from the moment you step inside. Located on Orchard Street in the Lower East Side, Scarr’s exudes a unique vibe that is hard to resist.

One of the things that set Scarr’s apart is its commitment to quality ingredients. They mill their grains in-house, which translates into delicious thin-crust pizzas that are simply divine. Every bite is a testament to the effort and care they put into making their dough.

In addition to their mouth-watering pizzas, Scarr’s also offers a variety of tropical cocktails that perfectly complement their pies. This combination of good food and great drinks is what makes Scarr’s stand out from the rest.

1. Bleecker Street Pizza | New York Pizza Slices

Bleecker Street Pizza | New York Pizza Slices

All hail the best in the town: Bleecker Street Pizza. 

Believe it or not, it’s been voted as the best pizza joint for three years in a row. Now, that’s a record that is hard to beat. Their secret lies in a multitude of things. From structuring the pizza slice in a perfect triangle to bearing a thin yet delectable crust, it truly is unbeatable. 

Additionally, their expertly crafted blend of cheese and sauce offers a delightful sweetness that is sure to leave you craving more.

Now, Bleecker Street Pizza gives you a world of options to choose from. A variety of shapes, slices, and toppings are at your disposal. Maybe you could indulge in their house special, buffalo chicken, or chipotle chicken. 

Although they also offer salads and pasta, the pizza is the star of the show and it’s easily the reason why folks flock to this establishment.

There you have it, New York City’s plethora of pizza options will make you dizzy. 


Get CASH BACK ON ALL TRAVEL with WayAway Plus. Enjoy 10% off on us with ‘Wanderful10’.

Use our favorite resource to find the best hotel and home rental deals in NYC or use the link below.

Find the cheapest flights to LaGuardia, Newark and John F. Kennedy

Plan the rest of your trip to NYC with our favorite sightseeing tours. 

Disclaimer:  This post includes affiliate links.  If you click on one, we may receive a small, but wanderful commission at no extra cost to you.  Thanks for WANDERING with us!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Cookie Consent with Real Cookie Banner